Tuesday, April 20, 2010

Monday, April 19, 2010

Anotated Bibliography of Resources

References

D'Agata, Charlie. 2005. “The Upside of British Health Care” [video] CBS News. CBS.

This clip off the CBS News site tells the story of an American living in Britain and the treatment she received for her breast cancer. It gives an overview of how the system works and the time it takes to receive the medical assistance. In this news broadcast, it helps to have the example of someone receiving the treatment, rather just hearing how the system works. The video can be found at:

http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=4894902n&tag=api.

Ham, Chris. 2005. “US and UK health care: a special relationship?” British Medical Journal 330. Retrieved March 5, 2010 (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC554041/pdf/ bmj33000597.pdf).

This article from the British Medical Journal compares the United Kingdom's healthcare system with the one in the United States. It also mentions how Britain is interested in learning from the U.S. System. This includes ideas such as the United States policy on chronic disease. The United States, however, has very little interest in learning from the National Health System.

National Health System. “NHS Choices.” Retrieved March 5, 2010 (http://www.nhs.uk/Pages/HomePage.aspx).

This is the official website for the National Health System. The site covers a large variety of topics. Everything from information on health problems, medical advice, health news, and even where you can find and choose services. The website is very large, but easy to navigate. It was designed be easy to navigate by many different types of users.

Pemberton, Max. 2010. “Finger on the Pulse: The NHS should not fund homeopathy.” Telegraph, March 8. Retrieved March 8, 2010 (http://www.telegraph.co.uk/health/healthadvice/ m axpemberton/ 7375006/Finger-on-the-Pulse-The-NHS-should-not-fund-homeopathy.html).

Since the application of the National Health System in the UK, the system has evolved to cover more than just basic healthcare. The issue is where to draw the line. This news article from the Telegraph newspaper in England discusses how the practice of homeopathy should not be covered by the NHS. Based on research findings, the practice of homeopathy does not work any better than placebos and therefore the NHS feels no need to include it under their system. The option to use homeopathy will still be available, just not with any funding from the NHS.

World Health Organization. 2010. “World Health Organization.” Retrieved February 15, 2010. (http:// www.who.int/en/)

The World Health Organization is huge resource for studying the health systems in different counties. It has an entire section on their website set aside just for countries. There are also various news articles, projects, and data listed on their site, as well as. There is also a section dedicated to talking about who explaining the World Health Organization is, and proves that it is a very credible resource.


UK vs. US Healthcare

In America, the ideology is the rich receive better treatment. This expands across many categories: better clothes, better houses, better hired help, and better health care. The privatized health care system in the United States allows for better and possibly more advanced treatment. Health insurance is designed to help cover some of the excessive costs of medical care, but policies are often very confusing, and come with many restrictions and loopholes. There are also positives to the system, however. There is flexibility in being able to choose a physician, and the time it takes to receive health care is fairly prompt. Of course, one must be able to qualify and afford the insurance for it to be of value.

There are also a large number of people in the US who are uninsured, which creates problems. These people are usually unemployed or underemployed to the point that they just cannot afford the added expense. Someone in this position may postpone seeking help, and, when help can no longer be delayed, they may run into serious financial and worsening medical problems. Someone wealthy who has suffered from a medical emergency has a better prospect for recovery given that they would seek help sooner than someone who lives in poverty and suffers the same fate. Other countries have adopted a variety of different health care systems. One that the privatized U.S. health care system is often compared to is the National Health Service that was instituted by the United Kingdom.

The National Health Service was adopted in 1948 (National Health Service). The idea was to provide free health care to those in need, regardless of income. While the system is still essentially free for everyone, there are some prescriptions that cost money, but it is mainly funded by taxes (D'Agata 2005).

Who makes up the National Health Service?

The system employs more than 1.7 million people. The Chinese People's Liberation Army, Wal-mart, and the Indian Railways are the only businesses that employ more people (National Health Service). While the National Health System is comprised of the multiple countries that make up the United Kingdom, England is by far the largest part of the system. It employs 1.3 million people that serve a population of 51 million (National Health Service).

Where does the money come from?

The English system is funded directly from taxation. The government feels this is the fairest way to fund the system. It costs the average British citizen £1,980, or $2979.24 annually (National Health Service).

Where does the money go? (make a graph) for slide

In England, sixty-percent of the NHS budget goes to employees salaries. Another twenty-percent helps to cover the costs of buildings, equipment, and training, while the last twenty-percent is used to pay for drugs and other supplies (National Health Service).

How effective is the National Health Service?

Since the NHS has been instituted, the life expectancy in the entire UK has been rising and the infant mortality rate has been falling (World Health Organization 2010). Based on surveys, patients seem content with the care they receive from the NHS.

Even though the system is very different from the one in the US, there are similarities between the two. The main cause of death in both is heart disease, and the life expectancy is comparable (Ham 2005). However, neither organization compares favorably to the high achieving systems in Japan and Sweden (Ham 2005). Regardless of the pros and cons, similarities and differences, there will always be people for or against the structure of the systems. It is obvious that the healthcare system has shown vast improvements in the overall well being of the citizens of the UK.




References

D'Agata, Charlie. 2005. “The Upside of British Health Care” [video] CBS News. CBS.

Ham, Chris. 2005. “US and UK Health Care: A Special Relationship?” British Medical Journal, 330. Retrieved March 5, 2010 (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/ articles/PMC554041/pdf/bmj33000597.pdf).

National Health System. “NHS Choices.” Retrieved March 5, 2010. (http://www.nhs.uk/ Pages/HomePage.aspx).

World Health Organization. 2010. “World Health Organization.” Retrieved February 15, 2010. (http://www.who.int/en/).